Thursday, March 6, 2008

How did organized religion begin?

There's a great song from the '80's by XTC called 'Dear God' (it's been covered by Sarah McLachlan and others). It starts as a rant about humankind and how we've let the world go to pot. Then it changes course and becomes a rant at God - ending with the singer singing that he doesn't believe in God. In the chorus there's a line that has always struck me as very poignant - Did you make mankind after we made you? Interesting question, especially for a non-believer (like my brother the Atheist). Before I was a believer it's something I pondered quite often. When you look at all of the wacky religions out there that are clearly man made (Scientology comes to mind, along with any religion that asks you to cut off your own genitalia, kill your parents, eat garbage from a dumpster, live under the sea, etc), so many are easy to define as having a Deity that was created by the worshipers. But for the big 3 (Christianity, Judaism and Islam), how did they originate? Of course I believe that Christianity and Judaism are real in the sense that God communicated with man after creating the world. And I know the roots of Islam are in the old testament with Mohamed having a revelation from God. But somehow we all got organized and moved our beliefs forward, while Greeks and Romans, Norse and Egyptians all lost their faith... why? Why did these 3 take off? I know I'm leaving off Hinduism and a few others. But focusing on these 3 you've got 5000+ years of history - what the heck else has lasted some statically for 5000 years? It's almost a basic part of society. Doesn't that help (logically) with the relevance of Judeo-Christian beliefs? Surely if it was all made up people wouldn't be as passionate over the years to keep them alive and thriving. Whole empires have risen and fallen during the centuries, yet these 3 religions stay strong... it's interesting to me.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

David,

Don't forget, Scientology isn't a religion, more like Amway meets organized crime. That's probably why Thom didn't mention it in his book. And it's so incredibly easy to make fun of Scientology, what's the point? As for religious beliefs, or lack thereof, try two films that shaped my distrust of religion. 1. The Seventh Seal 2. The Passion of Joan of Arc.
I'm enjoying your blog and will get Thoms book soon.

Best,

Chris

Thom said...

Joan of Arc is a perfect example of the point made in one chapter. The question being, "When is talking to God just plain crazy?" It's not crazy when it's Abraham being told to sacrifice his son, or when John the disciple is being given the Revelation visions, or when Jacob has a rough-and-tumble night with an angel (or was that God in the cave, with the charlie horse in His thigh?) or when Mohammed is being told to recite the Koran (once again, in a cave). Then comes Joan of Arc, and more recently Joseph Smith and David Koresh.

At what point do we start differentiating between divine vision, con artist, schizophrenic, and just plain crazy as a racoon in a dumpster?